The compliment that insults a pastor

A few paragraphs from my journal of Tuesday, March 30, 1993. I had been at that church two and a half years…

At 2 pm, I had a visitor. A former church member who will go unnamed here wanted to apologize for his being so critical of me in my first year.  Couldn’t identify why he was, except a certain resistance to authority.

I forgave him.  The pain is that he is a minister of sorts, someone I had a lot of confidence in and did not know he was doing this. He said, “I hear from people in the last month that you have changed.”  Why am I offended by that? I said, “I haven’t.  I’m the same person I was then.” Which is true. 

Reminds me of the pain in (my last church) when people would write and say, ” We love you now, but for your first year here, we hated your guts. You were in our pastor’s pulpit.’ (The previous pastor had stayed only 3 years and had left for another church before they were ready.) And these would be dear people whom I had valued.  They got It off their chest and left me bleeding. 

Anyway, I’m making a real effort to leave it with the Father and to go forward. (end of journal)

Pastors know this feeling all too well….

Someone will think they are giving you a compliment by saying, “Your preaching has been so good…lately.”  Or, “I was telling someone the other day, you are a far better preacher than when you first came here.”

Those kind of compliments are better left unspoken. What they do is stick a knife in the heart of the preacher.  What they are is digs and jabs over his perceived failures previously. What they accomplish is to ease the conscience of the speaker while adding more burdens to the preacher.

Why do some people think they need to confess a sin they harbored in their hearts but shared with no one? I do not need to know that someone disliked me “then,” and thinks I’m worthier “now.”  (Note: The usual formula is that the confession should be as public as the sin. So, if my transgression was only “in my heart,” then the confession may be limited to the Lord in private. Imagine the fallout if a man confesses to a woman that he had harbored lustful thoughts of her! Horrors!)

One wonders how church members came to see their job as issuing progress reports on the preacher’s pulpit abilities.  “He’s better.” “He’s the same.” “He’s worse.”

Show me that in the Scriptures.

I suspect the answer has to do with the Reformation when the pulpit ministry became central to worship. Previously, the Eucharist (the Lord’s Supper) occupied center place in worship, as it still does in Catholic and more liturgical churches.  But Protestant churches–even down to their architecture–are centered on “the preaching of the cross.”

From there, I suppose it’s a short leap to the flock deciding some preachers are better at this sermon delivery thing than others.  Doubtless, even in the 16th Century, after Martin Luther’s followers had multiplied and preaching became more prominent, people must have gravitated to the churches with the best preachers.

So, maybe I’m railing against something as permanent and fixed as the rising of the sun in the east. But it’s still worth saying.

Let us pray for the pastor and…

–and let us keep our critical opinions to ourselves, or give them to the Father in prayer.  (If the sermons are truly disasters, every church should have a small team of leaders who are able to work with the pastor on this or any other problem.  Church members do not take this upon themselves.)

–give thanks to the Lord for every good thing God does through our pastor.

–ask the Father to attend to his daily schedule since conflicts rise from every side and daily the Lord’s pastor is forced to choose which needs he will meet and which to ignore.

–let us speak well of him to other people. Let us not demand that he be perfect or flawless before earning our commendation. Let us show grace to the pastor by speaking well of him to others.

–let us speak up when someone is unfairly characterizing or criticizing the pastor. Let us not stand idly by when God’s man is being attacked by someone who is clearly out of fellowship with Christ.

What “speaking up” means…

Perhaps we could include a note here on how to “speak up” when we hear someone running down the preacher.  Assuming they are not addressing you, but you overhear the remark, then I suggest you walk over to where they are talking and do nothing. Do absolutely nothing. Just stand there.  Button your lip.  Say nothing.

Walk up close to them, as near as the talkers are to one another.  In silence.

Your silent presence will convict the culprit of his/her wrongdoing more than anything you might say.

If yours is a church where this scenario might well play out–that is, if people criticizing the pastor happens from time to time–then I suggest you rehearse before going into action..  Imagine you come upon a small group in the hallway, and hear them running the preacher down.  Imagine walking over and standing uncomfortably close to them.  Imagine saying nothing but just looking at each one, in turn.  Imagine standing there in silence as long as it becomes necessary. (The longer the silence, the deeper the conviction will penetrate and the longer it will endure, I promise.)

Do not misunderstand…

I’m not urging anyone to concoct a praise report about the pastor out of thin air.

Praise and encouragement should be given only when appropriate. What I am suggesting is that we find ways to encourage the ministers without attaching a barb to the compliment, without using the praise as a bait to sink the hook into the Lord’s man.

How we treat the preacher, God takes personally.

I did not make that up. The Lord takes personally how His spokesmen are treated. It’s straight out of the Scriptures, in two easily-remembered passages, Matthew 10 and Luke 10.

“He who receives you receives me…” (Matthew 10:40).

“He who hears you hears Me; he who rejects you rejects Me, and he who rejects Me rejects Him who sent Me” (Luke 10:16).

Who among us would not like to brag on Jesus? Imagine having the opportunity to tell Him what a great job He’s doing and how much you appreciate Him.

It’s far easier than you might think.

Go tell the servant Christ sent how you value his ministry. And show him even.

Jesus will interpret that as you telling Him. And how good is that?




5 thoughts on “The compliment that insults a pastor

  1. Thanks for responding. I will call Jack Newton at Parkview Baptist and see if they may be interested in hearing about their ministry.
    Great to hear from you. I pray all is well.

  2. Very informative. Our Pastor has shepherded our church for 20 years. I sure hope I have never said anything negative to him. He came at age 25 and has hung in their with us through thick and thin. You can imagine the trials and triumphs in that length of time. Thank you, Bro. McKeever.

  3. I am about 30 states away and have read your blog faithfully for a few years now. So I will never meet you or really know you, but I’m so sure that you have no idea how much you’re loved.

  4. I think you take Matthew 10 and Luke 10 out of context. The “you” is ALL believers not just “preachers” or what you really mean “pastors”. If a Christian does criticize a pastor he should do it either privately 1 on 1 (Matthew 18) or if it is serious he should do it publicly in front of everyone (Galatians 2).

    I must say that I find the “tone” of this message to be arrogant. It is the “pastor is God’s anointed” and cannot be criticized no matter what sermon. This is a serious problem in the church and has been for centuries. The pastor (Bishop) has elevated himself above the “sheople” and lord’s himself over them. While many pastors are loving and really do care about the sheople, they still lord it over them like a benevolent dictator. If criticized they are so thin skinned they embrace the “I am a victim” mentality.

    I served for 12 years as an elder / associate pastor. I saw my pastor slipping. I attempted to talk to him many times, but he was always able to avoid me for years. I still did my duty and served, preach, and taught. I mentioned nothing to anyone in the congregation, even when they came to me to complain about the pastor (they did not want to confront him so they go the the other Elder). Finally I got the chance to speak to him one on one. His response: He decided to not speak to me anymore until I would be so frustrated I would leave the church. This was Dec 2010 – March 2011. Why did he do this? Because he could. I did not leave right away. I followed Matthew 18 to the letter. Even when some men of the church (one of them a professional mediator) agreed to meet together he refused. Why? Because he could. The final stage, bring it before the church, I did not do. I let it go rather than be divisive.

    Five years later I found that the majority of pastors agree with how my pastor handled me. Ignoring and dismissing fellow Christians is very common among pastors. If one is not praising the pastor then that person is mere rubbish. This is so common sociologists just published a book about it called “Church Refugees”. So before you assume that it’s me and my imagination maybe you should read that book.

    • It would appear you are an authority on arrogance, sir. Jesus is instructing the disciples about the reception they will receive when going out to preach and you decide that does not apply to them but to everyone. Nice little leap of logic here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.