When the Pastor Speaks on Homosexuality

It is true that the Bible identifies a number of sexual practices as wrong and to be shunned by the Lord’s faithful. It is true that homosexuality is among these. It is likewise true that the New Testament sees homosexuality as no worse than adultery and other kinds of transgressions.


Those other areas do not pose as great a problem for the pastor who wants to address them. He can preach against adultery and lust and pornography all he wishes and he will not enrage anyone.


The subject of homosexuality (gay, lesbian, bi-sexuality, however we wish to phrase it) is a minefield for the man of God. Almost anywhere he steps, he takes a chance of stirring up something from one direction or the other.

As the new pastor of a church, I was pleased to get a phone call from a local television station inviting me to speak. New preachers are always glad to get before the community; it helps get their ministries off to a roaring start. But this one I turned down.

“We are putting together a panel to address homosexuality,” the news director said. “We’ll have two gay/lesbian speakers and two ministers. Would you be willing to be one of the ministers?”

No thank you. Not in a hundred years.

There are indeed a few Christian leaders around who can pull that off, but I’m not one of them. This had all the makings of a shouting match or worse, an opportunity to hold the Christian message up to ridicule. Both are to be avoided.

This week, a friend of mine emailed to get my input on a discussion her denomination is conducting on this subject. Here is her note to me and my response.

Hi Joe,

I’m in need of some advice. This month, I’ll be in a meeting where we will be discussing our feelings about homosexuals in leadership positions in our denomination. The diocese has held several of these meetings and this will be the last of the series.

Our pastor says we must go and “defend the faith.” He went to one last week that was “packed.” After the general meeting, everyone breaks into small groups and they talk about their beliefs. The pastor was in a group of 14. Only four of them, himself included, spoke against homosexual leadership.

I believe that the Bible makes it clear that homosexuality is wrong. What do I say when and if someone brings up passages that say slavery is okay and that women are second class citizens, etc.?

Our pastor says that at his meeting a woman priest said any kind of sexuality is okay as long as no one is harmed. He was astonished and said, “Then prostitution is all right, I assume. Everyone has a good time, so what could be wrong with it?”

I do plan to pray that God will help me find the right thing to say, but I could use some help from you.

Here is my response.

Dear Marilyn,

For me, I Corinthians 6:9-11 is an important teaching on this subject. (Stop and read it before going further.)

Here are six points on that text, as I see it….

1) It’s so critical that we say nothing to imply that the people on this list–fornicators, idolaters, homosexuals, sodomites, thieves, covetous, drunkards, revilers or extortioners–are not welcome in our churches. They are welcome. We want them in church.

Those who take the opposite view from ours want to pain us into the corner of rejecting homosexuals altogether. We must not let them do that to us.

2) But we want gays in church as people in need of ministry, and not as ministers themselves.

3) Note that Paul says, “Such were some of you.” But not now, no longer.

4) Something has changed them. “You were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus and by the Spirit of our God.”

5) Before any of these people can be used of God as His servants, they must be changed so that their named behavior is in the past tense. For that to happen, they must be washed (cleansed, forgiven), sanctified (set apart for holy purposes), and justified (making them right with God).

6) Two points I frequently make to pastors who tend to be condemning toward all homosexuals–

–a. Notice the company of the homosexuals here. Let us not be harder on them than on those with more respectable sins. The Scriptures have nothing good to say about adultery, drunkenness, or idolatry either. These people are likewise excluded from ministry (or, they should be).

–b. If the church at Corinth was reaching them for the Lord, Marilyn, they could not have had a sign out front announcing “Fags will burn in hell.” They must have been loving them into the kingdom. That’s a huge point for the church of today that is trying to find a clear path on this subject.

My strong conviction is that those wishing to put homosexuals in places of leadership in the church today are taking their cues from the world. God told Israel in Deuteronomy 28:13 that if they would obey Him, He would “make you the head and not the tail.” The head is the leader and sets the direction; the tail meekly follows along.

In the church today, many of us have become the tail. The world tells us what will be acceptable in clothing and hair styles, in language, in recreation, in priorities for life. When we allow the world to decide what will be trendy and cool and respectable, the church timidly and passively falls into step behind it. In so doing, we lose our voice for God.

Something is bad wrong with this.

You asked what you should say when our opponent raises the issue of slavery, saying it was approved in the New Testament. The point seems to be that the Bible should not be our authority on these matters since it says things we know not to be true. In that case, we may as well forget about calling ourselves Christians. If our authority is “whatever the world establishes as correct,” we are no longer disciples of Jesus Christ.

Keep in mind that the speaker’s aim is primarily to get you off-message. Don’t let them.

The clearest and quickest answer to the slavery-as-taught-in-the-Bible claim is the second greatest commandment: “Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself” (Matthew 22:39). The New Testament has nothing good to say about slavery and when Christ’s message was applied, put it out of business.

Since the New Testament is our authority, we look to it to discover its teachings on various subjects. If we do not do that, the discussion is over before it has started.

9 thoughts on “When the Pastor Speaks on Homosexuality

  1. doesn’t the verse in corinthians say homosexual offenders? it’s my understanding that the only way to lose your salvation is thru blasphemy of the holy spirit is that correct? if i’m not blaspheming against the holy spirit, but i fell in love with a woman then am i not still going to heaven?

  2. Thanks for this blog post on Homosexuality. Your view is pretty much where mine is. My problem is I have one who thinks I ought to preach against it strongly and frequently from the pulpit. And because I said, or Eugene and I said, we can love th sinner, he thinks we love the act itself. eugene has him in his SS class and he gives the class fits over this subject. Hope all is well.

  3. Wise words, Dr. Joe. I’ve also thought our Catholic brothers were on to something in not condemning a person for having homosexual feelings (although not condoning either), but condemning only the acting out on those feelings.

    A couple of additional observations:

    1) Many Christians find it easy to call down the brimstone on homosexuals because it is “safe” sin to be against; i.e., most of us have never faced homosexual temptations.

    2) Those who speak out most stridently against homosexuals are usually hiding some bestting sin of their own.

  4. What would you say to a person that you already knew, in a position that the subject had never come up and later found out he or she was homosexual?

  5. Ever notice how disquieting the lists are in the NT if you take each point seriously? For example, in the above list Paul includes such innocent sins as covetousness, reviling (surely not if you’re reviling gays), and extortioners. Now I can really get into preaching against gays and other sexual sins, and thievery. But why did he have to stick in covetousness as if it were every bit as bad as those wicked sins. How come I might want to upgrade my vehicle to match my neighbor and that’s as bad as being gay? And did you ever look at that Revelation list as to who is cast in the lake of fire? Of course, there’s no society of coveters and revilers makeing waves. Maybe we could start one?

  6. This is the second time I’ve received this article and I feel compelled to comment on it this time. The United Methodist Church is teetering on the edge of committing spiritual suicide and we need to pray that they will back away from the edge. The Confessing Movement Within the United Methodist Church is organizing at the grass-roots level to return Methodism to the teachings of John Wesley. Do we have any homosexuals attending Cammack UMC. Yes we do, as a matter of fact he is my cousin. But I want you to know that he is not the only sinner that darkens our door. Can he be a member or an officer – NO! But according the the Methodist Discipline that is one of many sins that can keep a person out of church membership. Thanks, Joe, for the good word. I may use this one in the near future. God bless.

  7. Man is this ever quicksand. It has been stated by many that homosexuals are made that way and they really did not have a choice. As our scientist dig deeper and deeper into human DNA what do we say if they find that indeed there are genes that cause a person to be homosexual just like genes that cause a person to have brown or blonde hair? Did God make a mistake?

  8. You can rationalize and justify any sin you commit and that is what is happening in our society today. Because of a lack of strong Bible preaching and teaching, many churches feel that they can accept any kind of lifestyle and continue to call themselves christian. You do not have to be a Greek scholar to read and understand Romans 1. Every place in scripture where sodomy is mention, it is condemned. Just giving sin a nice sounding name does not justify it in the sight of God, especially when He has condemned it. God help this nation….

Comments are closed.