“Whatever was I thinking?”
I’ve said that. And I’ve sometimes thought it about other preachers whose sermon illustrations just got entered into the competition for dumbest story of the year.
A “dumb” story in this piece, refers to an account of something that distracts from God’s message, or sucks all the air out of the room so that no one hears anything for the next 15 minutes, or overpowers the sermon so the story is all anyone remembers for the next week, or is mind-bogglingly offensive. Or is just plumb stupid, did we say that?
Most of us preachers have been guilty of telling one or two of those over the years. Or a hundred.
Consider this a call for greater discernment in selecting stories and illustrations, parables and news items for our sermons.
1) A story that overpowers the sermon and smothers whatever point you were making is unworthy and needs to be tossed.
Have you heard the one about the dad who went fishing with his son and the boy’s friend?